Toronto FCNew York City FC
- 1Sean Johnson
- 28Raoul Petretta
- 5Kevin Long
- 17Sigurd Rosted
- 6Kosi Thompson
- 21Jonathan Osorio
- 23Maxime Dominguez
- 20Deybi Flores
- 7Theodor Corbeanu
- 10Federico Bernardeschi
- 38Charles Sharp
- 49Matt Freese
- 24Tayvon Gray
- 80Justin Haak
- 13Thiago Martins Thiago Martins
- 22Kevin O'Toole
- 55Keaton Parks
- 32Jonathan Shore
- 10Maxi Moralez
- 17Hannes Wolf
- 16Alonso Martinez
- 26Agustin Ojeda
