New York Red BullsColumbus Crew
- 31Carlos Miguel
- 12Dylan Nealis
- 15Sean Nealis
- 3Noah Eile
- 37Mohammed Sofo
- 44Raheem Edwards
- 19Wikelman Carmona
- 8Peter Stroud
- 75Daniel Edelman
- 10Emil Forsberg
- 13Eric Maxim Choupo-Moting
- 28Patrick Schulte
- 2Luis Marcelo Herrera
- 31Steven Moreira
- 18Malte Amundsen
- 27Max Arfsten
- 7Dylan Chambost
- 25Sean Zawadzki
- 16Taha Habroune
- 8Daniel Gazdag
- 9Wessam Abou Ali
- 10Diego Rossi
