New York Red BullsChicago Fire
- 31Carlos Miguel
- 12Dylan Nealis
- 3Noah Eile
- 26Tim Parker
- 81Serge Ngoma
- 20Felipe Carballo
- 75Daniel Edelman
- 5Omar Valencia
- 37Mohammed Sofo
- 13Eric Maxim Choupo-Moting
- 10Emil Forsberg
- 1Chris Brady
- 36Justin Reynolds
- 5Samuel Rogers
- 4Carlos Teran
- 15Andrew Gutman
- 23Kellyn Acosta
- 35Sergio Oregel
- 6Rominigue Kouame
- 11Philip Zinckernagel
- 9Hugo Cuypers
- 19Jonathan Bamba
