New York City FCColumbus Crew
- 49Matt Freese
- 24Tayvon Gray
- 80Justin Haak
- 13Thiago Martins Thiago Martins
- 22Kevin O'Toole
- 17Hannes Wolf
- 21Aiden Connor O'Neill
- 10Maxi Moralez
- 8Andres Perea
- 16Alonso Martinez
- 7Nicolas Fernandez
- 28Patrick Schulte
- 2Luis Marcelo Herrera
- 31Steven Moreira
- 21Evgen Cheberko
- 18Malte Amundsen
- 30Hugo Picard
- 16Taha Habroune
- 6Darlington Nagbe
- 27Max Arfsten
- 9Wessam Abou Ali
- 8Daniel Gazdag
